Is Nantucket Worth Visiting? Our Honest Review
As you’re checking off your New England bucket list, you may be wondering, is Nantucket worth visiting?
We recently took a trip to Nantucket, and in this post I’ll be sharing our first impressions, favorite spots, and final verdict of our time on the island.
Plus, read on to find out why it might not be the place for you.
Is Nantucket Worth Visiting? Here’s My Take
In one word, absolutely! From the moment we stepped off the ferry, it felt like we had been transported into a different world. The charming cobblestone streets greet you right away, lined with quaint shops, cozy bookstores and inviting restaurants just waiting to be explored.
Everywhere you look, there are vibrant flowers spilling over window boxes, and the iconic gray shingled siding on nearly every home and building makes it feel quintessentially New England.
Is a Day Trip to Nantucket Worth It?
Yes! Even if you only have one day, the island is small enough that you can see a lot in just a short amount of time.
Stroll through the historic district, pop into a few local shops, grab a bite at a waterfront restaurant, and you’ve already experience a good slice of what makes this island so special. So yes, even a quick visit is more than worth it!
We’ve even made a day trip Nantucket itinerary just for you!
Note: If you are only staying one day, be sure to take the first high speed ferry of the day to extend your time on the island. The two companies with high speed ferries are Hy-Line Cruises and Steamship Authority. Traditional ferries take over 2 hours to reach Nantucket from Cape Cod, which would really eat into your day.
Must-See Spots
To make the most of your time in Nantucket, there are a few places I would consider must-see spots!
Downtown Nantucket
Exploring downtown Nantucket is a must, especially since the ferry drops you off right at the heart of it all. One highlight is the Whaling Museum, where you can discover the island’s rich maritime history and learn about its whaling heritage.
Leave plenty of time for a leisurely stroll down the cobblestone streets, popping in and out of shops and bookstores. Don’t forget to grab some homemade ice cream and waffle cones at The Juice Bar. It’s a Nantucket staple!
Bluff Walk
While not everyone chooses to venture out to Siasconcet (or “‘Sconcet”), I think it is a must-visit part of the island! You can easily take the WAVE shuttle, Uber, or even bike to this area.
One of the highlights of Siasconcet is The Bluff Walk, a breathtaking coastal trail that literally goes through the backyards of some of the islands most beautiful homes. While you admire the homes on one side, the other side is even more stunning with the sparkling ocean and beach views.
For more details on this trail, check out our complete guide to the Sconset Bluff Walk.
Iconic Lighthouses
Did you even visit Nantucket if you don’t see a lighthouse?? I recommend visiting both the Sankaty Lighthouse and Brant Point Lighthouse if time allows.
The Sankaty Lighthouse is located in Sconset, just north of the Bluff Walk. This red and white lighthouse is one of my favorites, with views of the Sconset Golf Course and the Atlantic.
If you’re spending your time in the downtown Nantucket area, make sure to stop at the Brant Point Light house. Just a short walk away, this beautiful, petite lighthouse offers beautiful views and is a perfect spot for a quick photo op or a peaceful moment by the water.
The Beach
Visiting the beaches of Nantucket is a highlight for most travelers. Two of the most popular beaches are Surfside Beach, known for its great waves and family-friendly atmosphere, and Cisco Beach, which is famous for its vibrant surf culture and nearby Cisco Brewers.
Nantucket Weather
The weather in Nantucket is a huge draw for visitors. The temperature varies by season and is an important factor to consider when planning your visit.
Summers are warm and pleasant, with temperatures in the mid-70s to mid-80s, making it perfect for beach outings and outdoor activities.
Spring and fall offer milder temperatures in the 50s and 60s, ideal for hiking and enjoying the island’s natural beauty with fewer crowds.
Winters can be cold, often in the 30s, yet often not as cold as its sister island, Martha’s Vineyard.
Tips for First-Time Visitors
- Some businesses and restaurants close during the winter. Keep this in mind if you are traveling during this time of the year.
- Always bring a jacket or wear layers. Coastal weather can change quickly, and it is often windy on the ferry.
- Wear comfortable shoes if you are exploring the island by foot.
- There’s really no need to rent a car. Riding the WAVE shuttle, renting a bike, and walking are all efficient ways to get around Nantucket and see the highlights of the island.
- Consider visiting Nantucket during the shoulder seasons (late Spring and early Fall). We visited during the week after Labor Day and it was an incredible time of year to go! The weather was perfection and the summer crowds had dispersed.
Why You Might NOT Want to Visit Nantucket
Though Nantucket quickly stole our hearts, I know everyone has different tastes when it comes to travel destinations, and what feels magical to one person may not be the same for another.
Here are a few reasons why Nantucket might not be a good fit for you:
- Sea Sickness: The ferry ride is 1 hour and depending on the day, the ride may not be completely smooth. If you are susceptible to sea sickness and don’t have a working remedy, a different destination might be preferable for you.
- High Prices: It’s no secret that Nantucket comes with a high price tag. From accommodations to dining, everything seems to be on the pricier side. Even locals say prices are high “just because they can be”. So if you can’t stomach paying $10 for an ice cream cone, this might not be the place for you. (Choosing a day trip rather than an overnight stay can greatly reduce your costs!)
- Crowds: Nantucket can get quite crowded during peak season, which may take away from the peaceful, idyllic vibe you’re hoping for. Visiting in the shoulder seasons of just before Memorial Day or just after Labor Day is often preferred.
Final Thoughts on Nantucket
To sum it up, I absolutely loved my time on Nantucket and found its charm and beauty truly captivating. Whether you’re drawn to its picturesque streets, stunning beaches, or rich history, I believe there it has so much to offer travelers.
If you’re looking for your next getaway, I wholeheartedly recommend adding Nantucket to your travel bucket list!
For more help planning your getaway, read our Nantucket day trip guide and our complete comparison between Nantucket vs. Martha’s Vineyard.
As you plan your New England itinerary, consider adding a Newport, Rhode Island weekend getaway–another one of our favorite coastal towns we know you’ll love too!
Keep Exploring the Northeast:
- Martha’s Vineyard vs. Nantucket: Which Island Should You Visit?
- Your Perfect Day Trip to Nantucket
- Your Perfect Day Trip to Martha’s Vineyard
- The Ultimate Newport, Rhode Island Weekend Getaway
- Newport Gilded Age Mansions Trolley Tour Review: Is it Worth It?
- Is Visiting Nantucket Worth it? {Our Honest Review}
- Newport’s Iconic Cliff Walk: Pro Tips for First-Timers
- The Ultimate 4-Day Washington, D.C. Itinerary
- The Best Bike Tour of Washington, D.C.’s Monuments and Memorials
- How to Spend One Epic Day in Washington, D.C.
